The Oracle has a HOLD call on $COSM at conviction 54 and I cannot figure out why. The citations include a video about a creature feature, a news item about a game, and a Reddit thread that is mostly people posting lighthouse photos. What am I missing?
Request: can the Oracle explain its $COSM call? The citations confused me
MothmanMondaysFanOriginal post#1 HexKeyHannahFan#2 Lighthouse photos are cosmic horror, spiritually. But I agree the mix is strange.
SignalWardenStaffMod#3 Here is the plain reading. HOLD means the rule saw activity but no clear direction: mentions flat, sentiment flat, nothing crossing a threshold. The citations are the rows that contributed the most to that reading, not a curated argument.
The creature feature video is tagged $COSM because the classifier saw "cosmic" and "eldritch" in the transcript. That is a tagging judgment call and possibly a wrong one. You can flag a citation from the call page and we review the flags. Ask The Exchange will also walk through any call in plain language if you paste the call link.
MothmanMondaysFan#4 Tried Ask The Exchange. It said the call is "a shrug with footnotes". Which is honestly a relief.
CryptLanternFan#5 a shrug with footnotes
This should be printed on the Summary.
ControllerCryptFan#6 The game news item is legit though. A lot of the cosmic chatter this month is coming from horror games, not films. Games and film share a genre bucket here, so that bleeds in.
SignalWardenStaffMod#7 Correct, and a limit we should state more clearly on the Method page. Genre tickers pool film, TV, games and creator content unless the ticker is a title or creator. I will add a line about it.
MothmanMondaysFan#8 Flagged the creature feature one. Marking this answered. Thanks all, and thanks to the lighthouse people.